Searching: Are JSTOR articles peer-reviewed?

Follow

Comments

3 comments

  • Avatar
    Ryan Arthur Louque

    I can't think of a single reason not to feature an option to search peer reviewed material or at minimum mark items that are. 

  • Avatar
    Bonnie

    Hi Ryan! This was an intentional decision, but I'm going to reach out to my colleagues to find out information beyond this article for you. I'll update soon! 

  • Avatar
    Bonnie

    Hi Ryan! From our content management team: 

    Often, we don’t know the peer review status of individual articles, so it’s just not feasible for us to have a filtered search on the article level. 

    Putting labels on the issue level could be misleading as well as since not all contents within the issue will be peer-reviewed.  For instance, some include editorials and commentaries.  On the journal level, as the help text indicates, there is older content within the same publication that may not be peer reviewed in the standard process, and we wouldn’t be able to accurately reflect information about changes to a journal’s peer review process.

    Additionally, going back in time--scholarly, highly-vetted, but older materials may be of an excellent standard for their time, but they were not subjected to a peer-review process.

    I hope this helps! Thanks for your patience as we found an answer for you, but let me know if I can be of further assistance. 

Please sign in to leave a comment.